Lawsuit filed because of French Bulldog’s Death on Alaska Airlines Flight
French Bulldog’s Death on Alaska Airlines Flight
Michael Contillo, a San Francisco resident, has filed a lawsuit against Alaska Airlines, alleging negligence that resulted in the death of his beloved 3-year-old French bulldog, Ash. According to the complaint filed on October 16 in San Francisco County Superior Court, Contillo had purchased first-class tickets for himself and his dog to provide Ash with ample space and minimize contact with other passengers.
Breach of Contract and Negligent Handling
The lawsuit alleges breach of contract, negligence, negligent hiring and supervision, and negligent infliction of emotional distress. Contillo asserts that Alaska Airlines breached its contract by failing to accommodate his first-class purchase and by moving him and his dog to coach shortly before takeoff. This move, he claims, caused Ash to become anxious and develop health issues that ultimately led to his death.
Veterinary Examination and Compliance with Airline Policies
Prior to the return flight, Contillo had the bulldogs examined at a veterinary hospital to ensure their health and fitness for the journey. The veterinarian confirmed that both dogs were healthy and cleared them for travel. Contillo followed Alaska Airlines’ policy by reserving both dogs in the cabin, paying the additional fees, and transporting them in compliant carriers. Initially placed in the fourth row, they were later requested to move for safety purposes.
Resistance to Move and Warnings of Potential Health Risks
Contillo expressed concerns about moving the dogs before takeoff, explaining that it would make them anxious and cause breathing and heart problems, which could be life-threatening. He emphasized that they were calm in their current location but would become agitated amidst a full cabin. Despite his warnings, the airline employees allegedly ignored his concerns and insisted on the move.
Onset of Distress and Ash’s Death
Upon moving to the new seats, Ash started exhibiting signs of distress, breathing rapidly and heavily. Contillo was instructed to close the carrier, which he complied with. When they reached a certain altitude and he could check on Ash, he found that the dog had stopped moving. By the time they landed in San Francisco, Ash’s body was in rigor mortis, indicating that he had been dead for several hours.
Alleged Lack of Compassion and Communication
The lawsuit alleges that the crew and pilot showed no compassion or concern for Contillo’s loss. They failed to offer condolences or any assistance in the aftermath of his dog’s death. As of the lawsuit’s filing, Contillo had not received any communication from the airline regarding the incident.
Increased Risk for Short-Nosed Breeds
The American Veterinary Medical Association warns that short-nosed breeds, such as French bulldogs, are more susceptible to respiratory problems and more likely to die on airplanes than dogs with normal-length muzzles. The organization recommends that such breeds be transported in the passenger cabin.
Legal Claims and Damages
The lawsuit seeks punitive damages to be determined at trial. Contillo contends that Alaska Airlines employees should have been aware of the necessary precautions for transporting short-nosed breeds and should have avoided the actions that led to Ash’s death.